You’re Not Indecisive, You’re Experiencing Decision Fatigue
You can make a smart call on a big client issue, solve a messy problem in your business, and talk someone through a tough situation. Then you stand in front of your closet for 20 minutes, or you freeze when someone asks a simple yes or no question. It can feel ridiculous, and it can make you wonder, Why am I like this? Why can’t I just decide?
What you’re dealing with is decision fatigue, and it hits neurodivergent people (especially ADHD women running businesses) in a very real way. You’re not broken, and you’re not failing some basic adulting test. Your brain is doing exactly what it does when its resources run low.
Decision fatigue is mental exhaustion
Decision fatigue is what happens when you’ve made too many choices, and your brain runs out of fuel for making more. A useful way to picture it is the phone battery analogy.
The phone battery analogy (and why it fits ADHD so well)
Think of your decision-making capacity like a battery. Every choice drains it a little. Some choices drain it a lot.
With an ADHD brain, you often start the day at something like 60 percent, not 100. You also drain faster because your brain has to spend more effort on things that look “simple” from the outside.
By afternoon, you can hit power save mode. That’s when small choices start to feel impossible, even though you handled bigger, harder decisions earlier. It’s not because you stopped caring. It’s because your brain is protecting what it has left.
That’s the part many people miss. Decision fatigue can look like procrastination or stubbornness, but it’s often a resource issue. Your brain is trying to prevent a full crash by shutting down anything that costs too much mental energy.
For a deeper explanation of how decision fatigue shows up for neurodivergent people, you can compare your experience with Psychology Today’s overview of coping with decision fatigue.
The “tiny” decisions are what drain you first
When you think about decision-making, you probably picture the big stuff: pricing, offers, content strategy, hiring, or whether to pivot your business. But the big surprise is how many choices you make before noon.
You’re making thousands of micro-decisions that don’t feel important in the moment, but still pull from the same mental battery. Things like:
- What time to wake up
- Which task you’ll start first
- Whether you answer a text now or later
- What words you use in an email
Each one seems small. Together, they add up fast.
Then add business ownership on top of regular life. Your day can include constant choice points like: Should you post this? Is this the right price? How should you structure this offer? What color should the button be? Should you respond now or wait until you have more info?
By midday, you might have already made hundreds of decisions. That’s why it makes perfect sense when you can handle a complex business situation and then blank on what you want for lunch. Lunch is not “easy” when your brain is already maxed out.
This is also why typical productivity advice can fall flat. A lot of it assumes your brain has a steady supply of decision energy all day. When your battery is already low, every new choice feels like one more app running in the background.
Why decision fatigue hits neurodivergent people harder
Decision fatigue can hit anyone, but it tends to hit neurodivergent people harder because several common ADHD traits make decision-making more expensive.
Executive function is already doing extra labor
Executive function skills include planning, organizing, initiating tasks, and shifting attention. When those skills take more effort, every decision comes with extra steps.
A simple choice can turn into a whole internal process:
- You plan what the choice impacts.
- You organize the options.
- You initiate the action.
- You manage the friction of starting.
That’s a lot of brain power for something like choosing a sandwich. It’s an extra tax on your brain, and it stacks up throughout the day.
Working memory makes options harder to hold
Working memory challenges can make it tough to keep multiple options in your head at once. So you re-check. You re-read. You re-open tabs. You re-run the same mental loop.
That repetition is exhausting, and it can make you feel stuck because you can’t “hold” the whole decision long enough to land it. You might also second-guess yourself because the details keep slipping, even when you care about the choice.
Emotional regulation and rejection sensitivity raise the stakes
This is the part that can turn a small choice into a high-stress event. When rejection sensitivity is in the mix, decisions can feel loaded with danger.
Your brain can treat the possibility of a wrong choice like a threat. Even when the outcome is minor, your body can react like it’s major: tension, dread, urgency, panic, shame.
So now it’s not just “What should I pick?” It becomes, “What if I pick wrong and it goes badly?” That emotional charge makes it harder to choose at all, because choosing means taking a risk.
If you want another angle on why small choices can feel so heavy, read Relational Psych’s explanation of ADHD decision paralysis.
The sneaky ways decision fatigue shows up
Decision fatigue doesn’t always show up as “I can’t decide.” It can look like a handful of behaviors that seem unrelated until you connect the dots.
One common pattern is freezing. You get stuck analyzing every option, trying to predict the best outcome, and trying to avoid regret. You might open a browser, start researching, and suddenly you’re deep in comparison mode without making progress.
Another pattern is the opposite: impulsive choices. You pick something fast just to stop the mental pressure. You buy something you don’t need. You agree to a commitment that sounded fine in the moment, but feels awful later. It’s not because you’re careless, it’s because your brain wanted the discomfort to end.
Decision fatigue also shows up as avoidance. Emails and messages can feel like landmines because responding requires a chain of decisions: what to say, what tone to use, what you can promise, what you’ll do next. So you put it off, even when you want to respond.
And then there’s irritability. When your brain is done, it can’t keep smoothing the edges. You might get snappy, short, or overwhelmed by small interruptions.
Those moments aren’t proof you’re difficult. They’re often your brain saying, “I need a break from choosing.”
For practical ways people simplify daily choices, you can compare notes with ADDitude’s tips for reducing ADHD decision fatigue.
Perfectionism makes decision fatigue louder and stickier
Perfectionism and decision fatigue feed each other. When you want the “right” choice, you can end up trying to outrun uncertainty with more information.
So you research. You read 47 reviews. You watch comparison videos. You build a spreadsheet. You try to account for every possible downside.
The problem is that more information often creates more friction. Now you’re aware of every drawback, every risk, and every corner case. That makes the decision feel heavier, not clearer.
At some point, you hit a wall. Then one of two things happens:
- You make a snap decision to escape the mental torture.
- You avoid deciding at all, because the decision feels too loaded.
After that, the self-talk can get harsh. You might call yourself indecisive or lazy. You might replay the moment and judge it. That judgment adds emotional weight to the next decision, which makes the next one harder. It becomes a cycle: pressure, research, stuck, escape, shame, repeat.
What helps is naming the pattern for what it is. Perfectionism is not “high standards.” In this context, it’s often a safety strategy your brain uses to avoid the pain of a wrong choice. When you see that clearly, you can stop treating the problem like a character flaw.
What decision fatigue is costing you in business and life
Decision fatigue is more than annoying. It can quietly steal your time, energy, and momentum.
When you spend three hours choosing an email platform, you lose three hours you could’ve spent sending emails, improving your offer, or serving people. When you’re too mentally wiped to choose a project, you end up choosing none of them. You can also lose emotional bandwidth. When your brain is overloaded, your patience gets thinner, and you might snap at people you care about.
The biggest cost is what happens to your growth decisions.
After you’ve made a hundred tiny choices, the decisions that actually move your business forward can feel too big to touch. You might avoid the offer restructure, the price increase, the pitch, the boundary, or the plan. Not because you don’t want it, but because your battery is gone.
You end up spending your best thinking on the small stuff, and postponing the choices that deserve your clearest energy.
Did you know I have a membership for women who want to improve their executive function skills? Check it out here.
Why “just decide” advice doesn’t help
“Just decide” sounds simple, but it’s based on a bad assumption: that your decision-making capacity is online and ready.
When you’re in decision fatigue, that capacity is limited. Telling yourself to trust your gut can backfire because your gut is overwhelmed and noisy. It’s like asking your brain to do a high-focus task with low fuel.
A pros and cons list can also become one more decision pile. Now you have to decide what counts as a pro, how much each pro matters, how likely each con is, and what the “right” weighting should be. That can turn into another spiral.
And “don’t overthink it” is often too late. Once the question is in your head, you might already be 15 tabs deep.
What helps more is accepting that decision-making uses real mental resources. Those resources can be depleted, and they can be replenished. That shifts the goal from “try harder” to “set up your life so you don’t have to decide so much.”
Start by noticing your decision fatigue patterns
Before you fix anything, you need a clear read on when decision fatigue hits you and what makes it worse. Not to judge yourself, just to get honest data.
Try these prompts and answer them like you’re taking notes, not taking a test:
- When does decision fatigue hit hardest for you? Morning when you face your to-do list, midday after you’ve made a ton of choices, or late afternoon when someone asks what’s for dinner?
- What type of decisions drain you most? Business decisions, personal decisions, or creative decisions?
- What does your self-talk sound like when you’re stuck? Do you talk to yourself with patience, or do you go straight to criticism?
Awareness is the first step because it changes how you respond in the moment. Instead of forcing a decision through a tired brain, you can recognize what’s happening and adjust your expectations for that part of the day.
When you freeze on a small choice after handling something big, it’s not proof you’re failing. It’s a sign your brain hit its limit for the day. Decision fatigue explains the closet standoff, the lunch paralysis, and the sudden urge to say yes just to end the pressure. Start by tracking when your battery drops, then protect your decision energy like it matters, because it does.
